Umpire Decisions Transformed: ICC’s Latest Move

Revolution in Cricket: Out with the Old, In with the New

Transforming Decision-Making: ICC’s Bold Move

The International Cricket Council (ICC) has taken a groundbreaking step in the realm of cricket by eliminating the ‘soft signal’ in Test matches. This significant change, effective immediately, ushers in a new era in how disputed catches are adjudicated, aligning them with the processes for run-outs and stumpings. The decision now rests solely in the hands of the third umpire, independent of the initial perspective of the on-field umpires.

Umpires’ Verdict: A Thing of the Past

Previously, the soft signal played a pivotal role when on-field umpires were uncertain about a catch and referred it to the third umpire. They would indicate their preliminary judgment – whether they believed the batsman was out or not. This practice, however, has sparked its share of controversies. The move to abolish it comes as an acknowledgment that the third umpire, equipped with advanced technology, is better positioned to make an accurate decision.

Clarity Over Confusion: Cricket Committees Agree

Sourav Ganguly, head of the Men’s Cricket Committee, illuminated this shift, noting that the soft signal had been a topic of discussion over recent years. “The committee deliberated this at length and concluded that soft signals were unnecessary and at times confusing since referrals of catches may seem inconclusive in replays.” This advancement isn’t limited to men’s cricket; the women’s game also adopts this new approach.

Case in Point: The Stokes Controversy

The need for this change was further highlighted by the words of Ben Stokes following a contentious decision in an Australia-South Africa Test: “ICC should get rid of the soft signal and let the third umpire who has all the technology make the decision when the on-field umpires send it upstairs, all the controversy is always around the soft signal given.”

Learning from the IPL: Paving the Way Forward

The Indian Premier League (IPL) had previously taken a similar stance in 2021 by removing the soft signal for decisions referred to the TV umpire, proving to be a successful experiment. This move by the ICC not only aligns with the IPL’s approach but also sets a new standard in international cricket.

Safety First: Mandatory Helmet Rule

In another significant development, the ICC mandates the use of helmets for batters facing fast bowlers, wicketkeepers at the stumps, and fielders close to the bat. Ganguly stressed the importance of this rule for player safety, marking a responsible and forward-thinking stance by the governing body.

Related Stories



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share article